Introduction
Boys And Girls Summary And Themes By Alice Munro Boys and Girls is a short story written by the Canadian author Alice Munro, first published in 1968. Munro is renowned for her mastery of short fiction, often using her stories to explore themes of identity, gender roles, family dynamics, and the complexities of human relationships.
In Boys and Girls, Munro delves into the formative experiences of a young girl as she navigates the transitions between childhood innocence and the realities of societal expectations, particularly those related to gender.
Set in rural Canada, Boys and Girls is narrated by an unnamed young girl who is coming of age in a family that runs a farm. The story centers around the girl’s observations of the roles assigned to boys and girls, particularly through the lens of her relationship with her brother, her parents, and the expectations placed upon her as she grows older.
Through her experiences, Munro explores the impact of traditional gender roles on the formation of identity and how the pressure to conform can affect an individual’s sense of self.
Summary of Boys and Girls by Alice Munro
Boys and Girls opens with the unnamed young narrator reflecting on her life on a farm. She lives with her parents, her older brother, and a range of animals, including horses that her father uses for work. The family is involved in the agricultural industry, and the narrator spends much of her time assisting with farm tasks, playing with animals, and enjoying the freedom of childhood. As a young girl, she does not immediately understand the societal expectations of gender roles, and she believes herself to be just like her brother, equally capable and deserving of the same freedom.
The narrator’s brother, who is older than she is, represents the traditional role of a male in the family and society. He is allowed to participate in activities that the narrator is excluded from, and this distinction forms the basis of her early understanding of gender difference. Despite her mother’s occasional remarks that she should be more “ladylike,” the narrator enjoys participating in chores such as feeding the horses and doing farmwork alongside her father. She does not yet grasp the significance of the gender roles that are slowly being imposed on her.
Read more
A pivotal moment in the story occurs when the narrator’s father discusses the possibility of selling a horse that has been born on the farm. The narrator is upset by the idea of the horse being sold, as she has become attached to it, and she strongly believes that her brother should take responsibility for it. However, it is her father who makes the final decision about the horse’s fate, reinforcing the gendered hierarchy that exists within the family. The narrator’s father holds the ultimate authority, and her brother is given more autonomy in making decisions, while she is expected to fulfill more traditional roles.
As the story progresses, the narrator becomes increasingly aware of the differences between the expectations for boys and girls. She observes that her brother is given more responsibility and is treated with more respect by their father, while she is expected to stay within the confines of domesticity. Her mother, who works hard to maintain the house, begins to make subtle comments about her daughter’s future role as a woman, urging her to accept her place in the home and to help with chores like cleaning and cooking. The narrator’s own growing awareness of these gendered expectations causes her to feel conflicted and disillusioned.
The tension between the narrator’s desire for freedom and her increasing awareness of gender roles reaches a climax when a specific incident occurs. The narrator and her brother are tasked with bringing a horse to the barn, but the narrator’s brother refuses to help because he has other obligations. The narrator is left alone to manage the horse, but when her mother tells her to stay inside, the girl rebels. She attempts to defy the gender roles that have been imposed on her, yet she is ultimately forced to submit to them. Her feelings of frustration and resentment toward her mother and father are intensified by the realization that these societal structures are beyond her control.
As the story concludes, the narrator comes to terms with the reality of her gendered existence. She begins to recognize that her future is inevitably shaped by these roles, and her rebellion against them becomes less about defiance and more about acceptance of her predetermined fate. The story ends with a poignant moment in which the narrator accepts her place in the family hierarchy, though she does so reluctantly.
Themes in Boys and Girls by Alice Munro
1. Gender Roles and Social Expectations
The primary theme of Boys and Girls is the exploration of gender roles and the societal expectations placed on individuals based on their sex. Throughout the story, the narrator is forced to confront the reality of these roles as they are shaped by the family structure, social norms, and the broader cultural environment. As the narrator becomes aware of the difference between what is expected of boys and what is expected of girls, she experiences a sense of injustice and frustration. Her desire to engage in activities typically reserved for boys—such as handling the horses or taking on more physically demanding work—conflicts with her mother’s insistence that she help in the home.
The narrator’s struggle reflects the rigidly defined gender expectations that women, in particular, face. The story serves as a commentary on the limitations imposed on women and the broader societal forces that encourage conformity. Munro’s depiction of the narrator’s internal conflict highlights the complexity of identity formation, particularly for women, and critiques the unfairness of these gendered divisions.
2. The Loss of Innocence and Coming of Age
Another significant theme in Boys and Girls is the loss of innocence and the transition from childhood to adulthood. The narrator begins the story with a sense of freedom and a lack of awareness regarding gender roles, believing that she is simply a person, capable of doing anything her brother can do. However, as the story unfolds, she becomes increasingly aware of the societal distinctions between boys and girls. This realization represents a loss of innocence, as the narrator is forced to confront the limitations that society has placed on her. The transition from childhood to adulthood is often marked by the discovery of these limitations, and the narrator’s internal struggle is a poignant representation of this process.
Read more
3. Family Dynamics and Parental Influence
The dynamics within the narrator’s family play a crucial role in shaping her understanding of gender roles. The father’s authoritarian figure and the mother’s traditional expectations of femininity are central to the narrator’s growing awareness of her place within the family and society. The mother, who expects the narrator to take on domestic duties, symbolizes the societal pressure for women to conform to traditional gender roles. Meanwhile, the father’s tacit approval of his son’s actions reinforces the idea that boys are given more freedom and autonomy than girls.
The narrator’s relationship with her parents is complicated, as she loves her father but feels increasingly alienated from him due to the gender-based expectations placed on her. She is also conflicted about her mother, whose seemingly conventional values force her into a role that feels unnatural to her. This tension between familial love and societal pressure is a powerful aspect of the story and highlights the complexity of family relationships in the face of rigid gender norms.
4. Rebellion and Conformity
The theme of rebellion and conformity is also central to the story. The narrator’s desire to resist the roles that are being imposed on her represents a form of rebellion. She yearns for the freedom her brother enjoys, yet is unable to escape the expectations placed on her by her family and society. Ultimately, her rebellion is crushed by the weight of these expectations, and she finds herself conforming to the traditional roles of women. This tension between rebellion and conformity reflects the struggle many individuals face when trying to assert their autonomy in a society that demands conformity.
5. The Complexities of Identity
At the heart of Boys and Girls is the theme of identity. The narrator’s struggle with her gender identity is portrayed with great sensitivity, and the story raises important questions about how identity is shaped by both internal desires and external forces. The narrator is torn between her own sense of self and the identity that society forces upon her. Her conflict is a poignant exploration of how gender roles and expectations influence an individual’s sense of identity, particularly in the process of growing up.
Q1: Why is the narrator in Boys and Girls never given a name?
The narrator’s anonymity serves to emphasize the universality of her experience. By not naming the narrator, Munro allows readers to focus on her identity as a young girl navigating gender roles, rather than on specific personal details. The unnamed narrator also represents the many girls and women who struggle with societal expectations, thus making her experience relatable to a broader audience.
Q2: What is the significance of the horse in the story?
The horse in Boys and Girls symbolizes the narrator’s desire for freedom and independence. Throughout the story, the narrator forms a connection with the horse and sees it as an embodiment of her own unrestrained spirit. When her father decides to sell the horse, it symbolizes the loss of the narrator’s innocence and the imposition of societal restrictions on her. The horse is a metaphor for the conflict between freedom and conformity, and its fate mirrors the narrator’s own struggles.
Q3: How does the narrator’s relationship with her brother influence her understanding of gender?
The narrator’s relationship with her brother plays a crucial role in her initial understanding of gender roles. At the beginning of the story, she sees herself as equal to her brother, capable of doing the same things he does. However, as the story progresses, she becomes increasingly aware of the distinctions between their roles. Her brother is treated as the more capable and autonomous figure, while she is relegated to domestic chores. This dynamic highlights the gender inequality that the narrator begins to grapple with as she matures.
Q4: What does the ending of Boys and Girls suggest about gender identity?
The ending of Boys and Girls suggests that the narrator’s struggle with gender identity is not something that can easily be overcome. Despite her initial resistance to the roles society wants to impose on her, she ultimately conforms to them. The ending highlights the pressure that societal expectations can exert on individuals, particularly women, and suggests that identity is often shaped by external forces beyond one’s control.
