Introduction
Before We Were Yours Summary By Lisa Wingate Lisa Wingate’s novel Before We Were Strangers offers a poignant narrative that spans decades, drawing readers into the intertwined stories of two families whose lives were irrevocably changed by a heartbreaking scandal in American history. Inspired by real events, the novel traces the lives of children taken from their families through illegal adoptions and forced separations during the early 20th century, revealing the devastating impact of these practices on those involved. Before We Were Strangers explores themes of love, loss, family, identity, and the courage to seek the truth, all framed within the context of historical wrongs that continue to affect generations.
The novel, at its core, is about the strength of familial bonds, the resilience of the human spirit, and the relentless search for answers that often leads to the uncovering of painful truths. Through alternating timelines, Lisa Wingate crafts a tale that is both heartbreaking and redemptive, drawing the reader into a historical injustice while showing the power of love to transcend time and hardship. It offers a sensitive yet gripping examination of the complicated nature of family, identity, and the pursuit of justice, as well as the emotional scars left by society’s past mistakes.
Summary of Before We Were Strangers by Lisa Wingate
Plot Overview:
Before We Were Strangers alternates between two timelines—one set in the 1930s and the other in the present day—highlighting the perspectives of two central characters: Avery Stafford and Rill Foss. Avery, a determined and successful attorney, lives in the modern-day timeline and finds herself drawn into a family mystery when her father, a prominent politician, is diagnosed with cancer. Avery’s quest to uncover the truth behind her family’s secrets leads her to investigate the mysterious past of her grandmother, whose childhood was marred by an event that still haunts the Stafford family.
The narrative also centers around Rill Foss, whose life in the 1930s was tragically altered when she and her siblings were stolen from their parents and placed into a notorious orphanage, known for its illegal adoptions and the exploitation of children. As Rill reflects on her past and her journey to reunite with her family, the reader is given a deeply emotional glimpse into the abuse and trauma faced by these children, along with their relentless pursuit of justice and family reunion.
Read more
The Story’s Two Timelines
- 1930s Timeline – The Foss Family Tragedy: The novel opens in 1939 with Rill Foss, a young girl of twelve, living on a riverboat with her parents and siblings. Rill is a fierce protector of her younger siblings, and their life, though difficult, is filled with love and family bonds. However, their world shatters when authorities arrive, forcibly taking the children away from their parents and sending them to an orphanage. This is where Rill’s journey begins—a painful, turbulent experience marked by fear, uncertainty, and separation from the only family she knows.
The orphanage, run by a corrupt woman named Georgia Tann, exploits the children for profit, selling them to wealthy families seeking to adopt. Rill’s mission to reunite with her siblings becomes a central element of the story as she navigates the dangers and heartbreaks of the foster system while trying to hold on to the memory of her lost family.
- Modern-Day Timeline – Avery’s Search for Truth: In the present-day timeline, Avery Stafford, a young attorney, uncovers the chilling story of Rill Foss and her family while investigating a family secret. Avery’s own father, a politician, is gravely ill, and the revelation of a hidden past forces Avery to confront the truth about her family’s involvement in the events surrounding Rill’s stolen childhood. As Avery begins to piece together the facts of Rill’s story, she realizes that her family’s legacy is far more complex and fraught with ethical dilemmas than she ever imagined. The investigation eventually leads Avery to a path of self-discovery as she grapples with her own identity and what it means to face the sins of the past.
Connecting the Two Timelines: The alternating timelines of the novel gradually converge as Avery uncovers the truth about the Foss family tragedy and the illegal adoptions orchestrated by Georgia Tann. Avery learns that her own family is entangled in this dark history, as her grandmother was directly involved in facilitating the adoptions. As Avery’s investigation intensifies, the impact of Tann’s corrupt practices and their effects on the families involved becomes ever more apparent. Rill’s story, long buried and forgotten, comes to light, and Avery realizes that her search for the truth is as much about seeking justice for the victims as it is about reconciling with her own family’s troubled past.
Climax and Resolution: The climax of the story comes when Avery, armed with the knowledge of the atrocities committed against Rill and her siblings, confronts the truth about her family’s role in the exploitation of children. The novel reaches its emotional peak as Avery and Rill’s paths cross, and the two women come to terms with the trauma they’ve endured in different ways. Avery’s reconciliation with her own identity, and her decision to use her position to advocate for those who were wronged, provides a powerful conclusion to the novel. The reader is left with a sense of closure as Avery begins to take meaningful action, using her newfound knowledge to right some of the wrongs of the past.
Themes in Before We Were Strangers by Lisa Wingate
- Family and Identity: At its core, Before We Were Strangers is about family—both the families we are born into and the ones we create for ourselves. Rill Foss’s story emphasizes the unbreakable bonds of family, as she fights to reunite with her siblings and preserve the memories of her lost parents. Avery Stafford’s journey, on the other hand, explores the complex and often uncomfortable relationships within her own family. Avery’s search for the truth reveals how deeply our family histories shape our identities, and how confronting the past can be a powerful means of self-discovery.
- The Legacy of Trauma: One of the most poignant themes in the novel is the legacy of trauma—how the pain and injustice experienced by one generation can affect the next. Rill’s suffering at the hands of the foster system leaves scars that endure throughout her life, just as Avery’s discovery of this dark family history forces her to reckon with the emotional and moral consequences of her ancestors’ actions. The novel underscores the lasting effects of trauma and the importance of addressing and acknowledging past wrongs in order to heal.
Read more
- Injustice and the Fight for Justice: The novel shines a light on the systemic injustice of illegal adoptions, particularly the practices of Georgia Tann, who stole children from poor families and sold them to wealthy couples. Rill’s search for her siblings and her desire for justice are central to the story, as she tries to make sense of the horrors that were inflicted on her family. Avery’s investigation into this dark history also serves as a means of fighting for justice, as she works to uncover the truth and bring attention to the legacy of abuse. Through both Rill and Avery’s journeys, the novel explores the importance of seeking justice, even when it requires confronting painful truths.
- Social Class and Economic Inequality: The theme of social class is also critical to the story, particularly as it relates to the orphanage and the exploitation of children from poor families. The novel reveals how Georgia Tann took advantage of the vulnerability of impoverished families, using her position of power to profit from the adoption of children. Rill’s story highlights how economic inequality creates an environment where vulnerable children are at risk of being exploited, and how the wealthy can manipulate the system for their own gain.
- Resilience and Hope: Despite the devastating events that shape the lives of the characters, the novel also emphasizes the themes of resilience and hope. Rill’s determination to find her siblings and Avery’s drive to uncover the truth are both testaments to the strength of the human spirit. The novel suggests that even in the face of overwhelming adversity, hope and perseverance can lead to redemption and change.
Read more
(FAQ)
1. What is Before We Were Strangers about?
Before We Were Strangers is a historical fiction novel by Lisa Wingate that follows two women—Rill Foss, a child stolen from her family in the 1930s and placed in an abusive orphanage, and Avery Stafford, a modern-day attorney investigating her family’s ties to the dark history of illegal adoptions. The novel explores themes of family, identity, justice, and the lasting impact of trauma.
2. Who is Georgia Tann, and what role does she play in the novel?
Georgia Tann was a real-life figure who ran a corrupt adoption agency in the 1930s and 1940s. In the novel, she is depicted as the villain who exploits children, stealing them from poor families and selling them to wealthy couples for adoption. Her actions serve as a key catalyst in Rill’s tragic story and the central mystery Avery seeks to uncover.
3. How does the novel alternate between timelines?
The novel alternates between two timelines: one set in the 1930s, focusing on Rill Foss’s experience in the orphanage, and another set in the present day, focusing on Avery Stafford’s investigation into her family’s past. These timelines gradually converge as Avery uncovers the truth about her family’s involvement in the exploitation of children.
4. What is the significance of the novel’s title, Before We Were Strangers?
The title reflects the theme of lost connections and the search for family. It speaks to Rill’s yearning to be reunited with her siblings, and Avery’s discovery of a hidden family history that changes her understanding of her own identity. It also highlights the idea that, before the trauma and separation, the characters were not strangers to each other—they were a family.
5. What are the main themes explored in the novel?
The novel explores themes of family and identity, resilience in the face of trauma, the pursuit of justice, social class and inequality, and the enduring power of hope. It examines how the past shapes the present and the importance of confronting painful truths in order to heal.
6. Is Before We Were Strangers based on a true story?
Yes, Before We Were Strangers is inspired by the real-life story of Georgia Tann and her illegal adoption practices, which affected thousands of children during the early 20th century. The novel fictionalizes the experiences of these children and their families, but it is grounded in the historical events surrounding Tann’s crimes.
7. Who would enjoy reading Before We Were Strangers?
Before We Were Strangers is suitable for readers who enjoy historical fiction, especially those interested in stories about family, justice, and resilience. It is also a great read for those interested in real-life historical events, particularly those involving social injustice and the exploitation of vulnerable children.
Read more
