Analyze the elements of a Vollendungsroman present in The Stone Angel.
Analyze the elements of a Vollendungsroman present– Margaret Laurence’s The Stone Angel (1964) stands as one of the most powerful and psychologically profound novels in Canadian literature. It portrays the emotional and spiritual journey of Hagar Shipley, a ninety-year-old woman confronting her past and the inevitability of death. While critics often read the novel as a Bildungsroman (novel of development), it more accurately fits into the framework of a Vollendungsroman — a novel of completion, in which an elderly protagonist undergoes inner realization, reconciliation, and acceptance toward the end of life.
A Vollendungsroman explores spiritual fulfillment and existential resolution, rather than external growth. It charts not the protagonist’s social advancement but their internal movement from alienation to self-awareness, from denial to acceptance. The Stone Angel exemplifies this genre through Hagar’s emotional reckoning, her symbolic journey toward self-understanding, and the novel’s cyclical structure that merges memory with mortality.
Understanding the Vollendungsroman
Analyze the elements of a Vollendungsroman present – The term Vollendungsroman comes from the German word Vollendung, meaning completion or fulfillment. While the Bildungsroman focuses on youthful development, the Vollendungsroman concerns maturity, retrospection, and the search for meaning at life’s end. It deals with the final phase of existence, often characterized by self-assessment, moral reckoning, and a struggle for peace.
The key elements of a Vollendungsroman include:
-
An elderly protagonist reflecting on the past
-
Inner conflict between pride and humility, control and surrender
-
A process of self-recognition or spiritual awakening
-
A confrontation with mortality and reconciliation with the self
-
Narrative closure suggesting psychological completion
Margaret Laurence’s The Stone Angel embodies these features through the consciousness of Hagar Shipley, who, though stubborn and proud, gradually confronts the truths she has long denied.
Hagar Shipley: The Protagonist of Completion
Hagar Shipley is introduced as an aged, physically frail woman who clings fiercely to her independence. She resists her son Marvin’s attempts to place her in a nursing home and rebels against the indignities of aging. From the very beginning, Laurence sets up Hagar as a character in the final stage of life — caught between memory and mortality, pride and vulnerability.
The novel alternates between Hagar’s present (at age ninety) and her past, unfolding as a series of flashbacks. This narrative structure itself mirrors the Vollendungsroman tradition, where memory becomes a vehicle for self-knowledge. As Hagar revisits her life — her childhood under her authoritarian father, her failed marriage to Bram Shipley, her alienation from her sons, and her lifelong emotional repression — she begins to perceive the patterns of pride, blindness, and fear that shaped her destiny.
Thus, the novel is not about external events but about the completion of inner vision. By the end, Hagar achieves not physical freedom, but psychological liberation — the courage to face herself truthfully.
1. The Journey of Self-Recognition
Analyze the elements of a Vollendungsroman present – A defining aspect of a Vollendungsroman is the protagonist’s confrontation with the self. Throughout The Stone Angel, Hagar resists self-pity and refuses to acknowledge her weaknesses. Her pride — inherited from her Scottish father, Jason Currie — prevents her from showing affection or admitting vulnerability. She prided herself on being strong, independent, and self-contained — but this pride isolates her from love and compassion.
Her most painful memories — the death of her younger brother Dan, her estrangement from her husband Bram, and the tragic loss of her son John — reveal how her inability to express tenderness led to emotional barrenness. For most of her life, she has mistaken pride for dignity and independence for strength.
The turning point comes when Hagar runs away to an abandoned cannery, seeking solitude and dignity. Here, isolated from the world, she experiences a symbolic rebirth — not of body, but of spirit. She begins to realize that her so-called independence has been a shield against love. For the first time, she acknowledges her own limitations and guilt, saying:
“Pride was my wilderness, and the demon that led me there was fear.”
This confession marks the beginning of her spiritual Vollendung — an awareness that completion lies not in control, but in surrender and acceptance.
2. Memory as a Path to Completion
In The Stone Angel, memory functions as a means of self-exploration. The novel’s structure — shifting fluidly between past and present — allows Hagar to relive her life not chronologically, but emotionally. Each memory serves as a step toward self-understanding.
Her recollections are not nostalgic but interrogative; they compel her to see the consequences of her actions. For instance, she recalls mocking Bram’s illiteracy, scorning her son Marvin’s quiet devotion, and idolizing John, whose tragic death in a drunken accident leaves her desolate.
Through memory, Hagar reconstructs not only the events of her life but also the emotional blindness that shaped them. The act of remembering becomes her spiritual journey — an internal pilgrimage through which she attains clarity and closure.
Thus, the journal-like narrative of The Stone Angel parallels the inward quest of a Vollendungsroman, where the protagonist’s self-reflection becomes the source of redemption.
3. The Symbolism of the Stone Angel
Analyze the elements of a Vollendungsroman present – The title symbol — the Stone Angel statue that stands over Hagar’s mother’s grave — serves as a powerful metaphor for Hagar’s life and the novel’s thematic essence. The angel, carved in marble, is meant to represent faith and grace, yet ironically, it is blind-eyed — its vision obscured by time and weather.
Similarly, Hagar’s pride and emotional rigidity render her spiritually blind for much of her life. She tries to live like the statue — cold, dignified, and unyielding — but this “stone” strength prevents her from genuine connection.
By the end of the novel, however, the symbol transforms. As Hagar’s body fails, her emotional hardness begins to melt. She becomes capable of compassion — toward Marvin, Doris, and even the nurses who care for her. In her final moments, she experiences a flash of empathy and understanding — the very human warmth she had long repressed.
Thus, the Stone Angel becomes not only a symbol of blindness and pride but also of transformation and redemption — the movement from stone to spirit, rigidity to grace — central to the idea of Vollendung.
4. Confrontation with Mortality
The Vollendungsroman culminates in the protagonist’s acceptance of death as an integral part of life. Hagar’s confrontation with mortality is gradual but profound. Initially, she fears the indignity of death — she resents dependency, weakness, and loss of control. Her decision to flee from home symbolizes a last attempt to assert her autonomy.
Yet, in the final scenes at the hospital, Hagar surrenders her fear and pride. Her act of asking for a sip of water from a nurse — something she once would have resisted — becomes a moment of humility and grace. It symbolizes her spiritual reconciliation with the world and with herself.
Laurence does not offer a melodramatic death scene; instead, Hagar’s end is quiet, dignified, and human — reflecting the Vollendungsroman’s emphasis on inner peace rather than outward glory.
5. Fulfillment Through Compassion
Analyze the elements of a Vollendungsroman present – Hagar’s transformation reaches completion when she finally shows empathy and tenderness — emotions she long suppressed. Her small acts of kindness and her final words to Marvin reveal that she has learned the value of love, not pride. In understanding her failures, she attains moral clarity, even if it comes late in life.
The Vollendungsroman suggests that completion is not perfection but acceptance — the ability to reconcile contradictions, forgive oneself, and find serenity. Hagar’s final awakening embodies this truth.
Conclusion
Analyze the elements of a Vollendungsroman present – Margaret Laurence’s The Stone Angel exemplifies the Vollendungsroman tradition — a narrative of spiritual fulfillment rather than youthful growth. Through the life of Hagar Shipley, Laurence explores the universal themes of pride, love, memory, and mortality. Hagar’s journey from denial to acceptance, from isolation to compassion, represents the completion of self-understanding that defines this genre.
The novel closes not with despair but with a quiet sense of reconciliation. Hagar, once stone-hearted, becomes capable of grace. In her final act of humility, she transcends her own pride, achieving a form of redemption. Thus, The Stone Angel stands as a profound study of the human spirit — illustrating that even at life’s end, one can awaken, forgive, and complete the long journey toward truth.
